“Keep the Poor Among You Always”

John 12:1-8

April 3, 2022

The Rev. Todd R. Goddard, Pastor

Rush United Methodist Church

John 12:1-8

Six days before the Passover Jesus came to Bethany, the home of Lazarus, whom he had raised from the dead. There they gave a dinner for him. Martha served, and Lazarus was one of those at the table with him. Mary took a pound of costly perfume made of pure nard, anointed Jesus’ feet, and wiped them with her hair. The house was filled with the fragrance of the perfume. 

But Judas Iscariot, one of his disciples (the one who was about to betray him), said, “Why was this perfume not sold for three hundred denarii and the money given to the poor?” (He said this not because he cared about the poor, but because he was a thief; he kept the common purse and used to steal what was put into it.) Jesus said, “Leave her alone. She bought it so that she might keep it for the day of my burial. You always have the poor with you, but you do not always have me.”

| Centering Prayer |

Allow me to clear up some confusion.

Mary, the sister anointing Jesus feet, and wiping them with her hair

Is not Mary Magdalene.

This was a medieval western Christianity legend

That attempted to connect her with an unnamed, sinful woman

From the Gospel of Luke (Luke 7:36-50).

This was and is an injustice to Mary Magdalen that is perpetuated to this day.

That unnamed, sinful woman from Luke 7

Also anointed Jesus feet and wiped them with her hair

While he was eating with one of the Pharisees

At his house in Jerusalem.

Likewise, the pair of sisters today, Mary and Martha,

Is not the Mary and Martha sisters

– Mary who sits at the feet of Jesus

while Martha waits on them hand and foot –

As depicted in the Gospel of St. Luke (Luke 10:38-42).

That pair of sisters lived in the region where Jesus began his ministry,

In the north,

In the region of Galilee.

Great story; different sisters.

John’s Gospel account of Mary and Martha

Is about a completely different pair of sisters,

Coincidentally also named Mary and Martha.

Mary and Martha were common names.

St. John’s narrative about Mary and Martha

Takes place in the south,

In a suburb of Jerusalem called Bethany, and

Includes a brother by the name of Lazarus.

You may remember,

Lazarus was dead, stinking, and rotting four days in a tomb

When Jesus came and raised him from the dead and brought him back to life.

Raising Lazarus from the dead, St. John records,

Led to some Jews in the crowd believing in Jesus and following him,

While others went to the Pharisees and the council in outrage.

The council decided to have Jesus arrested (John 11:45-57) and Lazarus killed (John 12:9-11).

Jesus withdrew further away from Jerusalem to Ephraim,

Near the wilderness, and

Remained there with his disciples. (John 11:54)

When Passover drew near,

Jesus makes his way back towards Jerusalem,

Stopping back in Bethany to have dinner with Mary, Martha, and Lazarus.

I wonder if Jesus inquired about Lazarus’ health?

“Did you walk towards the light?”

“Any lingering effects of being DEAD?”

Seriously, though,

Passover is near, and so too is Jesus’ hour.

A number of items from the Gospel of John,

About this act of love, followed by the confrontation with Judas Iscariot,

Catches my eye and

Captures my heart.

1. Smell.

The stench of Lazarus dead four days in a tomb. (John 11:39)

The smell of costly perfume made of nard,

Filling the house with fragrance. (John 12:3)

Death and life are contrasted in both scenes.

Corruption, on the one hand, and wholeness, on the other.

Smell calls the observant to attention.

Pause for a moment to smell.

Breath in deeply the smell of Mary’s perfume.

Imagine this house filled with its fragrance.

Rudyard Kipling wrote

“Smells are surer than sounds or sights

To make your heart-strings crack.”


Smell can be associated with a memory,

Good or bad,

That can last a lifetime.

The smell of costly perfume

Can be a foretaste of the Passion that is to come.

One can almost smell the newly crucified Jesus,

His corpse washed.

Nard smoothed into the skin.

His body wrapped,

Stuffed with myrrh and aloes and laid in a tomb. (John 19:39)

2. Anointing.

Jesus reports

Mary purchased the perfume

For his burial.

“She bought it so that she might keep it for the day of my burial.”

(John 12:7)

Kings are anointed at coronation.

Priests are anointed at ordination.

The newly converted are anointed by the Holy Spirit.

The dying are anointed on their deathbed.

The dead are anointed

recognizing new birth to eternal life.

This very day,

On the eve of Jesus riding triumphantly into Jerusalem

Jesus is anointed by Mary, the sister of Lazarus,

As a wonderful, beautiful, loving act of preparation

For Jesus to complete his mission:

To redeem the world,

Reconciling the world to God.

Too often, we experience the love of God, through Jesus His Son,

Moving in a single direction,

From God to humankind,

From God to me.

Mary is one of the rare examples of reversing love’s flow.

She loves Jesus,

Is willing to sacrifice greatly to show him love and compassion.

Mary returns to the Lord the love that first comes from God.

Mary’s love isn’t withheld.

It isn’t miserly or a mere token.

Mary takes a pound of costly perfume to anoint Jesus’ feet.

Mary’s love is extravagant, over the top, excessive, enormous;

Exactly like God’s love for you and me.

We may say we love Jesus.

We often talk about loving Jesus.

Talk is cheap.

Actions speak louder than words.

Mary’s act of love is actually demonstrating love for Jesus.

How might we do the same?

What can you and I do to actually show our extraordinary love for Jesus?

Love Jesus?

Show me.

Show the world.

3. Poverty.

It is impossible to separate Jesus from the poor.

The Gospel author of John

Recognizes how deeply entwined the message and meaning of Jesus

Is tied to how we respond to the poor of this world.

It is no accident that Judas Iscariot

… The one who was about to betray Jesus,

The one who kept the common purse

The one who robbed from it for his personal benefit …

Brings up the topic of the poor.

True, perfume that cost a year’s wages

could have been sold and given to the poor.

After his skimming, the poor would have probably received a fraction of the proceeds.

Judas wasn’t concerned for the poor.

But, John correctly notes that Jesus was.

Jesus brought good news in tangible ways to the oppressed and vulnerable.

He fed the hungry.

He healed the sick.

He returned the broken to wellness and restored them into community.

Jesus resisted oppressive and corrupt

political, religious, and social systems

That lay at the root cause of the worlds suffering.

There is an important insight to John’s Gospel

That comes from the ancient Greek.

Sometimes the present indicative form of a word

Matches the present imperative;

which is an academic way of saying

“maybe we should read Jesus’ statement not as indication of the way things are – ‘You always have the poor with you’

but as a command: … ‘Keep the poor among you always.’”

(With thanks to Lindsey Trozzo, as found at: http://www.workingpreacher.org/preaching.aspx?commentary_id=3993)

Keep the poor among you always.

Living a life of Christian piety is a life immersed in poverty.

One who understood and practiced piety was Francis Asbury.

A few years ago I read his biography,

“American Saint: Francis Asbury and the Methodist” by John Wigger.

Asbury rode thousands of miles on horseback

During the American Revolution and in the decades thereafter,

Preaching the Gospel,

Converting the masses,

Expanding the Methodist movement beyond the wealthy coastal cities

Deep into the wilderness and frontier.

Asbury owned little,

Gave most everything away,

Lived on the generosity of host families.

His primary concern was with the saving of souls,

Bringing people into a saving relationship with Jesus Christ,

Then discipling them by organizing people into class meetings.

Class meetings, patterned after the class meetings of John Wesley,

Were led by a lay leader,

Met regularly,

Served to support one another in their discipleship,

And to reach out and serve the poor.

It’s rigid discipline encouraged love and devotion;

A modest, pious Christian life moving on towards sanctification.

Asbury avoided the trappings of wealth and power,

Eagerly seeking the farmer, the slave, the common person.

Asbury avoided locating in the comforts of cities on the Eastern seaboard,

Preferring the interior wilderness of Virginia, the Carolinas, and Tennessee.

Boarding with a frontier family,

Warmed by their hearth,

Speaking of mortal and immortal concerns,

Warms the heart and quickens the soul.

Keep the poor among you always, Jesus commanded.

Opportunities abound to not just talk about poverty

But to do something about it.

One in five children in America live in poverty.

Of our total population, 48% are poor or low income.

At the same time, 1% of the population own 43% of the nation’s wealth.

The bottom 80% are left with just 7% of wealth.


And that’s just in America.

Love the Lord, the Great Commandment tells us.

Love your neighbor as yourself, it is quickly followed up.

When we can love our neighbors as extravagantly as Mary loved Jesus,

We will go a long way towards keeping the poor among us

And serving their needs.

Just as Jesus fed the hungry crowds,

So too can we feed those who are unable to feed themselves or their families.

Just as Jesus healed the sick,

So too can we make health care affordable and accessible to all who need it.

Just as Jesus railed against systems of injustice and oppressions of this world,

So too can we.

Dearly beloved,

Breathe deeply and smell the fragrance of Mary’s anointing perfume.

Be inspired to love Jesus,

Not just by our words,

But through our actions

With acts of love and charity.

Love God and

Love neighbors,

Especially our poorest of neighbors.

Roll up the sleeves and don’t be afraid of getting your hands dirty.

Serve the poor.

You’re doing the Lord’s work.

Keep the poor among us always.

Be God’s extravagant love.

Live modestly.

Embrace piety.

Live that you may please God.

Let the rest take care of itself.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s